Fresh Pizza, Big Flavor, Local Favorite

Welcome to Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs International, proudly serving communities across Idaho with handcrafted pizza, oven-baked subs, and family-friendly flavor everyone can enjoy. From Wendell and Jerome to Twin Falls, Eagle, and Buhl, we're known for fresh ingredients, generous portions, and made-to-order favorites that keep locals coming back.

Place an Order

Eagle

Buhl

Jerome

KImberly Rd

Blue Lakes Blvd

Wendell

Order Your Papa Kelsey's Favorites

Craving fresh pizza, hot subs, or comfort food made fast? Order online from Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs International for quick and convenient pickup at your nearest Idaho location. From handcrafted pizzas and oven-baked subs to wings, sides, and family favorites, everything is made fresh and packed with flavor.

Place an Order